Shower vs. Bathtub: Which Should You Choose?

Many bathrooms feature a shower and tub combination. Bath renovation contractors would be the first to say that this combination is very practical, efficient and versatile. You have the option to take a quick shower during busy mornings or a long bath to relax after a long day at work. However, a shower and tub combination has its fair share of disadvantages, such as being difficult to use for older adults or those with mobility issues. 

A shower and tub combination may have been the most popular in most bathrooms for a long time, but things are starting to change. These days, many homeowners are getting rid of the pairing and replacing either a glass-paneled shower or a freestanding tub. In some cases, some homeowners have a separate shower and tub, especially if they have the space and budget for it. 

Unfortunately, not all homeowners have the luxury to install a separate shower and tub in their bathroom space. As such, they will need to choose between the two of them. To help you determine which option best fits your bathroom remodel project, The Bathroom Store presents a guide to shower and tub renovation. 

Do Showers and Bathtubs Have Similarities?

Before we go through the differences between showers and tubs, let’s review the few similarities they share. 

• A Variety of Styles – Both showers and tubs come in a variety of styles. Showers come as either stalls enclosed with doors or curtains, or walk-in showers without the partitions. Tubs, meanwhile, are available in standard, freestanding (disconnected from the wall), soaking (deeper and wider than the usual), whirlpool with built-in water jets and walk-in designs.
• Multiple Materials – Showers can be made of any material available, from fiberglass to natural stone. Options for tubs are plenty as well, from affordable acrylic to luxurious cast iron.
• Therapeutic Water Flow Options – If you are looking for ways to make your shower experience more relaxing, showers and tubs can provide you with therapeutic water flow options. A rainfall or waterfall showerhead gives a feeling of natural rain, while whirlpool tubs release relaxing, massaging blasts of water.

What Are the Differences Between Showers and Bathtubs?

Choosing between showers and bathtubs is an important decision. Take note that your choice will affect the overall look and layout of your bathroom. The ideal option should meet your functional needs and suit your lifestyle. If you have a hard time making up your mind, here are some factors you should consider:

• Bathing Experience

First and foremost, take into consideration the bathing experience. Do you prefer taking baths or taking showers? If you look forward to a relaxing soak in the tub after a stressful day at work, a bathtub is the most suitable solution for you. On the other hand, a shower installation may fit more with your needs if you want a more efficient bathing experience and don’t want to spend a lot of time filling up a large tub with water. 

In addition, you should also consider your family members. If you have small children, a bathtub will be much easier for them to use. If you live with older adults or people with mobility issues, a shower space offers easy access. It can also be equipped with grab bars, non-slip tiles and benches to prevent falls. 

• Appeal and Customization

Both showers and tubs are available in a wide variety of styles. Before you decide, you need to determine what aesthetics you are going for. If you want your bath renovation to result in an elegant and contemporary bathroom look, a glass shower stall is more fitting and modern. If you want to give your bathroom a classic, old-school feel, you should consider a claw-foot tub. 

As for customization, keep in mind that there are typically more personalization options available for the walls of a shower enclosure. The options for walls include different colors, tile patterns, and textures. With a tub, on the other hand, you can only choose from a few different colors to complement your bathroom’s color scheme.

• Safety and Accessibility

Another crucial aspect to consider is the safety and accessibility features of your bathroom. This is particularly important if you have any family members with mobility issues. If this is the case, you may want to stick to a walk-in shower. Available with low thresholds or no threshold at all, this type of shower makes it easier and safer for anyone to enter and exit. Shower stalls can also be equipped with built-in seating so older adults can sit comfortably while bathing. 

Since traditional bathtubs are difficult for those with mobility issues to get in and out of, a walk-in tub is a popular bathroom remodel option for homeowners. Walk-in tubs have low thresholds with extra-wide doorways as well as built-in seating for a safer and more accessible bathing experience. 

• Durability and Maintenance

Nowadays, most showers and tubs are made from acrylic, an extremely strong and tough material. In addition to that, the color of shower enclosures and tubs is infused into the acrylic. Thus, you don’t have to worry about flaking or peeling issues.

Acrylic is also widely known for being non-porous. This makes it easier to keep the surfaces clean and free from mold and mildew formation. Whether you choose a shower or tub, all you have to do is simply wipe it with a damp cloth and a household cleaner to retain its brand new shine. 

• Bathroom Space

Don’t overlook your bathroom space when choosing between a tub or shower. Keep in mind that the average bathroom is about 40 square feet. A standard shower stall or enclosure generally takes up about nine square feet, which means this will take up less than a quarter of an average bathroom. Meanwhile, a tub takes up about 13 square feet, occupying about a third of the entire room. If your bathroom is on the smaller side, a shower might be the best option.

Regardless of what you choose, you’ll want to ensure the success of your bathroom renovation. To ensure your project goes smoothly, turn to the experienced team at The Bathroom Store. We offer top-quality shower installation services and more. Call us today at (701) 223-1008 or fill out our contact form to set an appointment.